Edinburgh in the dark months
The tourist calendar in Edinburgh is not the calendar the city lives by. When the summer crowds have gone home, the sun sets before half past four, and the Old Town becomes what it was always built to be: a dense stack of stone and chimneys that keeps its warmth in. If you can live with early darkness, November to February is a good time to come, and in some ways the best looking.
What the season gives you
Edinburgh in winter is a city of indoors that happen to be beautiful. The museums are quieter in the morning, and the light at midday, low and gold on the sandstone, is better than anything the long days of July can offer. Plan the outdoor hours between ten and three, and keep the evenings for what the city does best under a roof: a long dinner, a bookshop, a bar with a fire.
Where to sleep for the long evenings
Hotel Dundas Gardens is three Georgian townhouses joined by a garden, a few minutes from Princes Street. The drawing room keeps a fire lit in winter, rooms have tall sash windows, deep baths and wool blankets, and the small spa has a steam room for the end of a windy afternoon. Read the rules before you pick dates: the hotel asks for two nights when the stay includes a Saturday night, and on the Flexible rate it takes a deposit equal to the first night.
Cowgate Close Lodgings sits in a close off the Cowgate, a few steps below the High Street, in a converted law chambers with the original stairs and stone walls in the lobby. The rooms are modern and well soundproofed, and breakfast is served in the old courtroom. In the dark months its position is the point: a five-minute walk in the wind is pleasant, a twenty-minute one is a decision.
Stockbridge Water Inn has eleven rooms over a bright bakery-cafe beside the Water of Leith. Each room has a kettle and a shelf of local books, which is all the equipment a wet afternoon needs. The centre is fifteen minutes away on foot along the river path, and in the evening you may prefer to follow the street.
Timberbush Hotel Leith is a converted warehouse on the Shore, with exposed brick, iron beams and big windows facing the water. Seafood kitchens line the quay below, and a tram and frequent buses reach the centre in about fifteen minutes. Like Dundas Gardens, it asks for two nights on weekends that include a Saturday.
A short plan for a short day
- Go up to the castle when it opens, while the light is clear and the paths are quiet.
- Eat a proper lunch in the Old Town, then spend the afternoon in a museum, not on a hill.
- Walk the Water of Leith in the last of the daylight, from Stockbridge towards the sea.
- Finish in a bar with a fire, and order whatever the staff recommend.
Edinburgh rewards people who stop trying to see everything. Three nights is enough to do the castle, one museum, one long walk and several good meals, and the city will still have things left for the next visit.
Ready to look at dates? Every hotel above is listed on the Edinburgh page, with rooms, both rates and the full price for your stay.